Connect with us

Popular Science

The Experiment That Tried to Weigh the Human Soul

It’s a little complicated to weigh a dying person on a hospital bed, but that didn’t deter Duncan MacDougall. In the early 20th century, MacDougall’s unique bed-scale detected that 21 grams left the human body at the moment of death. He had finally discovered it: the weigh of the human soul … or so he…

Published

on

It’s a little complicated to weigh a dying person on a hospital bed, but that didn’t deter Duncan MacDougall. In the early 20th century, MacDougall’s unique bed-scale detected that 21 grams left the human body at the moment of death.

He had finally discovered it: the weigh of the human soul … or so he thought.

Read more about the cultural legacy of MacDougall’s flawed but influential experiment:

Continue Reading
Advertisement
32 Comments

32 Comments

  1. @benmcreynolds8581

    April 7, 2026 at 3:10 pm

    I learned about this from one of my all time favorite TV shows “Dark Matters: Twisted But True” ~I highly recommend checking this show out. I almost never see anybody talk about this show..

  2. @piconano

    April 7, 2026 at 3:14 pm

    God created this universe so that he could live in it as life, everywhere possible.
    There is no I. I am a part of God that will never die. Soul or not.

    • @littlefrank90

      April 7, 2026 at 5:12 pm

      good for you

    • @arcanics1971

      April 8, 2026 at 5:34 am

      Nah, it was the Cosmic Whelk who invented the universe. He did it one Tuesday evening after a particularly spicy vindaloo. May his Holy molluscular univalveness endure for eternity. Asnails.

    • @ross-carlson

      April 9, 2026 at 8:23 am

      Really, and which of the 2000+ “god(s)” are you talking about? Is it Hera? Thor? Yahwey? Vishnu? What part are you? How did you determine this? How did your “god” create the universe? What evidence do you have for ANY of this that I can test and verify for myself?

      See, we’re talking about science and reality here – if you wanna believe in your fairy tales great, go right ahead – but when you tell others the intelligent of us will want EVIDENCE – got any? No? None? Really, none? Oh, some bronze age book of fairy tales written by nomadic goat herders – really?

    • @ross-carlson

      April 9, 2026 at 8:23 am

      @arcanics1971 Really, but what about the great Spaghetti Monster? I heard he did it.

  3. @Absbor

    April 7, 2026 at 3:19 pm

    Meanwhile ebay: “you’re not allowed to sell something which doesn’t exist or parts of a human body.”

  4. @wizzelhoart

    April 7, 2026 at 3:27 pm

    was a great Movie. Del Toro was amazing

  5. @Richthofen80

    April 7, 2026 at 4:02 pm

    Haver-hill… someone not from massachusetts lol.

  6. @Jolfgard

    April 7, 2026 at 4:42 pm

    So 21 grams of what exactly? What is the carrier, or at least the physical correlate to a soul? And via which channel is it emitted from the body? I mean, if we can reliably replicate the phenomenon, the next step is trying to THOROUGHLY explain it.

    • @ross-carlson

      April 9, 2026 at 8:20 am

      Which of course you can’t do since the “soul” doesn’t exist other than a concept.

  7. @Baylow94

    April 7, 2026 at 5:10 pm

    6:19 One Piece Mentioned! Yo-Ho-Ho-HOOOOOOO
    The One Piec is REALLLLLLL

  8. @likealeica

    April 7, 2026 at 7:00 pm

    So Vsauce2 finally finished her transition, and she looks way better than I expected

  9. @msm1player

    April 7, 2026 at 10:58 pm

    21 grams would be about half the internet worth of data weight…. sounds right

  10. @Doppel_MM

    April 8, 2026 at 5:54 am

    2:43

    And that’s precisely the problem. Air HAS weight. If he didn’t measure any difference, then it’s due to his measuring method.
    A football without air weighs less than a football with air; it’s a matter of the accuracy of the instruments.

    So if he can’t even achieve that level of accuracy, how does he expect to weigh something like a soul?!?

    • @ross-carlson

      April 9, 2026 at 8:20 am

      Well given it doesn’t exist he’s not going to measure that anyway…

  11. @GamesFromSpace

    April 8, 2026 at 1:00 pm

    The generic keyboard beats don’t add anything to the video.

  12. @superdinoman

    April 8, 2026 at 4:02 pm

    If you double 21 you get 42, don’t panic

  13. @TomTwain

    April 8, 2026 at 6:15 pm

    Infuriating presentation… lost my concentration… really irritating BG music and ranty voice…👎

  14. @ernmalleyscrub

    April 9, 2026 at 7:24 am

    Ask stupid questions get stupid answers.
    Primitive ideas about how humans behave persist. Ghosts and spiritual rubbish fascinate immature minds.

    • @ross-carlson

      April 9, 2026 at 8:21 am

      Yes, yes they do – was happy to see another intelligent skeptic in the comments. Refreshing.

    • @bigpurplepops

      April 15, 2026 at 3:17 pm

      This is the most r/midwit or r/athiest type of bait I’ve seen since the 2010’s🤣

      Just smart enough to “call out” the giant, invisible, all-powerful entities not being there; just stupid enough to think they’re somehow the first to notice or not comprehend the reasons they’ve spread across every culture in history… classic.

  15. @ross-carlson

    April 9, 2026 at 8:26 am

    @6:41 Yes, we continue to exist in the memories of those that loved us. Beyond that? No, we’re dead.

    • @marilynb2643

      April 13, 2026 at 4:28 am

      Black Box 👽👽👽

  16. @Tweepx

    April 14, 2026 at 2:55 pm

    Would be cool if it was true, so far, no evidence of god or anything supernatural.

  17. @cabernetguy2000

    April 18, 2026 at 10:07 am

    All science videos should narrated and presented by Annie Colbert! She’s excellent at providing scientific material in short, clear and concise manner. Not to mention her subtle sense of humor!

  18. @cabernetguy2000

    April 18, 2026 at 11:43 am

    What about those soul-less people running around us and making everyone’s lives unbearable? Their souls surely weigh nothing, dead or alive!

  19. @Haggie

    April 19, 2026 at 10:47 am

    Even if dead bodies do weigh less, it doesn’t prove the existence of a soul. It only proves that some amount of weight is lost at death. They may as well claim that the weight loss at death proves that God exists.

    • @lizprince7944

      April 22, 2026 at 5:32 am

      That’s not how evidence works

  20. @ChargerX4u

    April 20, 2026 at 8:34 am

    If this is an example of what Popular Science has become I’m glad that I haven’t subscribed to it for decades! What a poor article and poor journalistic effort! Briefly: She says his experiments were flawed but doesn’t say how and after 100 yrs if someone has the knowledge and experience to determine how his experiments were flawed then that means they know how to conduct an unflawed experiment and so why haven’t they? Next, she says his work was debunked but doesn’t mention the man’s name who supposedly debunked the 21 gram experiments or how he supposedly debunked them. I’d like to know his exact methodology and any reference materials etc and a step by step account of how he debunked them. Then also I want to know who debunked the debunker? The article mentions one of the 6 people dying while he was adjusting the scales. Why? To add filler to the story? Why mention later things he did like using X-rays, more filler? Small sample size? Yes well ok. That is valid. But after 100 years why hasn’t anyone else added to the sample size? I’m sure if you offered terminal patients or their families some cash incentives to help pay their medical or funeral expenses etc that you would have an overwhelming supply of volunteers to participate in such experiments. And using today’s technology we could get much more accurate measurements.

  21. @Pall-q4w

    April 21, 2026 at 10:24 pm

    Gods, Devils, and souls are just pretend.

  22. @TSBII

    April 23, 2026 at 10:24 pm

    Good to see this channel back at it

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Popular Science

Would Permanent Daylight Savings Time Really Improve Our Quality of Life?

Whether you’re pro-Daylight Savings or pro-Standard Time, the science is clear: Switching *between* the two every year is terrible for human health. So why haven’t we stuck with one system all year? The answer is both scientific AND political. Hosted by Annie Colbert Reported by Tom Hawking Edited by Avital Oehler Written and Produced by…

Published

on

Whether you’re pro-Daylight Savings or pro-Standard Time, the science is clear: Switching *between* the two every year is terrible for human health.

So why haven’t we stuck with one system all year? The answer is both scientific AND political.

Hosted by Annie Colbert
Reported by Tom Hawking
Edited by Avital Oehler
Written and Produced by Matt Silverman

Continue Reading

Popular Science

Let’s launch our garbage into the sun!

Ummm, no. Earth is messy. So can’t we just send our junk somewhere else? Aside from the moral quandaries raised by such poor stewardship of our already disheveled solar system, Earthlings probably haven’t made a habit of beaming literal garbage into space yet because we simply can’t afford to. Full video: #pollution #science #space

Published

on

Ummm, no.

Earth is messy. So can’t we just send our junk somewhere else? Aside from the moral quandaries raised by such poor stewardship of our already disheveled solar system, Earthlings probably haven’t made a habit of beaming literal garbage into space yet because we simply can’t afford to.

Full video:

#pollution #science #space

Continue Reading

Popular Science

Americans loved drinking radioactive ‘miracle water’ in 1920s

Radithor promised to cure everything from wrinkles to leukemia, but its unintended results were deadly. Watch the full video:

Published

on

Radithor promised to cure everything from wrinkles to leukemia, but its unintended results were deadly.

Watch the full video:

Continue Reading

Trending